Justice Scalia on “Self-Righteous” Europe
In today’s Law in Action, on BBC Radio 4, US Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia gives a rare interview touching upon a few fascinating legal issues. Justice Scalia is one of the most controversial characters on the US Supreme Court; hailed by conservatives, and abhorred by liberals, for his approach to legal interpretation based on doctrines of originalism and (strict) textualism. This approach is in sharp contrast to the approaches seen in Europe, by for instance the ECJ, where norms of judicial activism are very much alive. Regardless of what one thinks of Justice Scalia he does have some interesting points on the issue of legislation, not just constitutions, being static instruments that do not evolve over time. Similarly, Scalia discusses the use of “smacking on the face” under the “ticking bomb scenario”, which is likely to cause offense. In addition, he has some good points on the appointment of judges in the US, which, he argues, is ultimately not any longer about the lawyerly...